top of page

You Can See Everything: The Stories We Live Inside

6 hours ago
5 min read

Archetypal Analysis: Nathan Fielder, Elizabeth Holmes, and the relationship between narrative and agency.

Sunday Nov 15, 2026

By Jessie Rivest

There is something fascinating about watching someone who appears to have lost authorship of their own story. While watching Nathan Fielder's You Can See Everything, I found myself recursively thinking about the archetype of The Storyteller, and what happens when that capacity becomes externalized.

Elizabeth's repeated insistence that she never lied was particularly interesting to me. Throughout the film, other people seemed to speak for her, interpret her, and construct narratives around her. She appeared to have difficulty owning the things she was saying, or connecting her words to the larger context in which they existed.

I began wondering what happens when someone surrenders not only their voice, but their sovereignty: their internal authority to interpret experience, establish boundaries, and author their own life.



When the Storyteller becomes externalized

The Storyteller is more than the ability to communicate. It is our capacity to create continuity between experiences, through humour, satire, layered techniques, and language - both verbal and non-verbal. It connects events, recognizes patterns, establishes context, interprets meaning, and allows us to articulate our own version of reality.


When this capacity is compromised, someone else's interpretation can begin to replace our own. Trauma can complicate this relationship. Sexual trauma, in particular, can affect memory integration, contextual awareness, emotional regulation, and the ability to construct a coherent narrative around experience.


Sometimes there is a skipping effect. Information arrives, but the connective tissue between what happened, what it means, and how to respond doesn't always form. The same phenomena occurs within the somatics of shame, often there's a skip as opposed to a smooth movement when slowing down and connecting feeling with the body.


This can make someone vulnerable to manipulation, particularly when they struggle to recognize contradictions between what another person says and what they actually do. This isn't to suggest that we can diagnose someone's trauma through observation, or that communication difficulties necessarily indicate a traumatic history. Rather, it offers a lens through which to consider how trauma can affect and even fragment a person's relationship with their own experience.



The Magician and the missing context

A specific moment that caught my archetypal eye, was when Nathan introduced the story of David Blaine putting a piece of glass through his hand, referencing the fact that the trick was real. Elizabeth's response seems to bypass the underlying implication. Rather than following the contextual thread Nathan is introducing, she appears to interpret it in an entirely different way.


The fact that he intuitively decided to throw in a story about a magician, when The Magician archetype was missing, is part of why I'm obsessed with this work. Opposites attract, attempting to fill in the gaps in nearly every energetic relationship.

The Magician card in the tarot is ruled by Mercury. Mercury governs communication, interpretation, translation, perception, and the movement of information between different contexts. The Magician understands how things are constructed. They recognize the trick, see the mechanism beneath the presentation, and understand that what appears to be one thing may actually be another.


The Storyteller, The Magician and Mercury can all be used interchangeably. My point is that we all have this frequency somewhere in our list of ingredients, some have more than others, naturally. But when it is at the bottom of the list, the person can lack discernment, and become very susceptible to the stories other people tell them.


The Dreamer, The Nurturer, and the loss of Sovereignty

Another archetypal pattern I kept returning to was the relationship between The Dreamer, The Nurturer and The Sovereign.


The Dreamer wants to believe in possibility. The Nurturer wants to accommodate everyone's needs. These are beautiful capacities, but without The Sovereign they can become self-abandonment.


We can become so invested in understanding another person's intentions that we stop evaluating their actual behaviour. We can become so committed to someone's potential that we abandon the evidence of who they currently are. And sometimes innocence becomes an identity that prevents us from developing thicker skin.


There is an important distinction here: being deceived is not the same as being responsible for someone else's deception. But there is also a developmental responsibility to cultivate our own capacity to recognize reality, establish boundaries, and exercise agency over time.


The Sovereign does not require us to abandon The Dreamer or The Nurturer or become cynical. It allows us to believe, love, and care without surrendering ourselves.


Two Mercuries: Nathan Fielder and Elizabeth Holmes

Seeing so much Storyteller in Nathan and so little in Elizabeth, despite her having a scientific mind, made me curious about their astrological contrast.

------

I will preface by saying that the archetypal model I use, frames that we all have 3 leading forces and 2 falling forces. The 3 that lead are the easiest to see running the show --- they take up the spotlight. The 2 that are falling are not simply less of that energy, but less developed and operate in shadow. Shadow placed archetypes are tricky. They have unknown qualities to the subject, patternize from protection and/or wounds, and often cause us the most harm and inner tug-of-war's in our lives. They can be related but not beholden to the planetary placements in our charts, and are not at all fatalistic, but symbolic maps for learning and discussing invisible things.

-----


Nathan Fielder, born May 12, 1983, has his Sun, Moon, and Mercury closely conjunct in Taurus. Symbolically, this creates a concentrated relationship between identity, emotional experience, thought, and communication.


His comedy often involves sustained observation with long, dry, awkward pauses. He takes an ordinary social situation and extends its underlying logic until its contradictions become visible.


Elizabeth Holmes, born February 3, 1984, has an Aquarius Sun, Pisces Moon, and Mercury and in Capricorn. Through an archetypal lens, this offers a different configuration: One who is seen innovating or doing things differently, is quite sensitive on the inside, and thinks practically/literally.


Her chart invites questions about the relationship between vision, emotional reality, communication, achievement, and the construction of an external identity. Astrology cannot explain or establish someone's behaviour, but it can provide symbolic language for examining these different ingredients. What interests me most is the relationship between emotional experience and narrative construction.


How do we know what we know? How do we distinguish our own perceptions from the interpretations of others? And what happens when the story we tell about ourselves becomes disconnected from reality?




The archetypal consequence

I keep coming back to the idea that we cannot indefinitely bypass the developmental demands of an archetype. The Lover cannot permanently substitute for The Sovereign. The Dreamer cannot substitute for The Strategist. The Nurturer cannot substitute for The Warrior.


Eventually, the neglected capacity demands development. The character demands the stage. The task isn't to eliminate these archetypes or diminish their influence. It is to develop a relationship with them that allows each one to contribute without taking over the entire psyche.


Innocence without awareness becomes aloof.

Love without sovereignty becomes self-abandonment.

Storytelling without authorship leaves someone else in control of the meaning of your life.


Perhaps the real work is learning to remain open to possibility while staying in relationship with reality. To love without losing our voice or values. To dream without abandoning discernment. And to never forget that just because you can't see everything, doesn't mean it isn't there.


If you want to explore your leading and falling archetypes in a supportive container, book a 45-minute session with Jessie here.






Comments


bottom of page